Skip to content

Revise FlyLab manuscript after multiple internal peer-review rounds - #5

Draft
pinkysworld wants to merge 6 commits into
mainfrom
codex/flylab-reviewed-manuscript
Draft

pinkysworld wants to merge 6 commits into
mainfrom
codex/flylab-reviewed-manuscript

Conversation

@pinkysworld

@pinkysworld pinkysworld commented Sep 21, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

The original manuscript made some model results sound more general than the available diagnostics could support. This revision makes the transferable contribution a computational audit of evidence transformations, graph dependence, and specification sensitivity. It keeps the MaleCNS case study while identifying where extract choice, runtime normalisation, null construction, and specification plumbing change the interpretation.

Changes:

  • Correct the chemical and statistical claims identified in the Fable/Opus, referee, Grok, and independent internal reviews. Dependence labels remain extract- and runtime-conditional; non-rejection is not equivalence, and component-level BH adjustment is not cell-level FDR control.
  • State the finite evidence-dispatch rules and their refusals, qualify synthetic recovery and cached scale results, and distinguish receptor-panel calculations from organism-level outcomes.
  • Reorganise the main manuscript around three methods questions; move reproduction to supporting engineering evidence and keep limitations adjacent to each result. The short Word preparation copy embeds four main figures and links the other archive artifacts.
  • Add the author-supplied name, affiliation, email and ORCID, a reproducible Word exporter, a DOCX input-hash sidecar, submission notes, editorial decisions, and tests. The manuscript body is approximately 5,665 words; venue-specific length and citation-format checks remain open.

Validation: 1,221 tests passed, 2 skipped, 12 slow tests deselected in the full run; 23 focused tests passed after export. The 16-page Word copy was rendered and visually inspected. Artifact-manifest and commit-attribution checks passed. The committed numerical JSON changes only manuscript word counts and editorial replay metadata; the numerical values and table CSVs were preserved.

The full numerical rerun was interrupted during dependence analysis. Large scale profiles remain cached. This PR does not claim independent circuit-level validation, animal outcomes, or a completed numerical reproduction. Before journal submission, mint an archival DOI, prepare a blinded review copy and supplementary-file package, verify declarations and references, and confirm the editor's format requirements. No journal submission has been made.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant