Skip to content

What does an initial look like in Devanagari, Bengali and the scripts like them? (एम. एस. वर्मा gives initials() 'ए. ए. व.') #1273

Open

Description

@derek73

#1191 stopped a Latin initial spelled out in a Brahmic script (एम. for M., এম., ਐਮ.) from reading as a title. It now reads as a name word. But nothing reads it as an initial. classify tags an initial by T5's shape, one word character and a period, and a spelled initial is two letters (एम.), or a letter and a vowel sign (बी., के.). Measured on master b76f278:

Input today what reads it
एम. एस. वर्मा given एम., middle एस., family वर्मा (right)
एम. एस. वर्मा.initials() ए. ए. व. R3 takes the first character: M., S., N., L. and F. all give ए.
बी. के. शर्मा.initials() ब. क. श. the same, and so before #1191
एम. tags none, so no rule that reads an initial (M4, O5, P7, C9, S10, O1) sees one T5
राम वर्मा एम.एस. suffix एम.एस. (suffix-or-name) S3 (the unlisted dotted suffix shape): #864's paired-initials exception needs a script with capitals
राम वर्मा, एम. डी. (M.D. spelled) given एम., middle डी., family राम वर्मा C1: neither word is a listed credential; CLDR's Marathi renderings write these

The shape question: in a Brahmic script, is a spelled initial an initial? If so, what marks one: a short word and a period (एम., बी., के., डी.), or a closed list of the spelled Latin letters per script? And what is its initial: the word itself (एम.) or its first character? The answer decides the other rows: the tag that rules read, initials(), whether एम.एस. is paired initials, and whether spelled credentials after a comma are listed vocabulary.

Where they occur: the 39 Lok Sabha names #1191 measured in in_sansad; nepal-candidates' Devanagari side (none moved under #1191, so to be measured); CLDR's Marathi fictional renderings.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions