Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension


Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion Cargo.lock

Some generated files are not rendered by default. Learn more about how customized files appear on GitHub.

52 changes: 52 additions & 0 deletions reviews/SR-20261113192641-ver-75-pr207-code-review.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192641
title: "VER-75 quire-cli PR207 code review"
type: SpecReview
analysis: code-review
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; PR #207 src/commands/trace.rs, src/commands/coverage.rs, src/commands/symbols.rs, tests/cli_trace.rs, spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, spec/functional/index.md, Cargo.lock"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

Ticket: VER-75. Code review with the Rust lane folded in, over the PR diff. Tests, formatting, Clippy, and cargo-deny checks passed. One medium compatibility defect remains: the new empty `formalizes` vector is serialized into every trace JSON response, contrary to the ticket's no-marker byte-preservation acceptance criterion.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | medium | `ClaimsSection.formalizes` is serialized even when empty, so a project with no formalizes relation gets a new `claims.formalizes: []` key in every `quire trace --json` result. VER-75 acceptance criterion 10 requires byte-identical output when the module declares no formalizes marker. Skip the empty field (or otherwise preserve the prior payload) and add a regression test for that case. | src/commands/trace.rs:224-228 |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-045-AC-1, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace --id <ID> --json` over a scope with a QSL `formalizes` marker lists the declaration under `claims.formalizes` only, with `claims.verifies` and `claims.implements` empty and `resolved` true."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-2, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace --file <PATH> --json` lists each declaration in the file under `claims.formalizes` with its resolved id."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-3, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "An id the corpus does not define appears in neither `quire trace` nor `quire symbols --json` output."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-4, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace --format tsv` emits one `formalizes` record per relation."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-5, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "When the scope has no `spec/` directory, a `quire trace` query succeeds and lists no `formalizes` relation, rather than failing on the missing document root."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-6, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Human `quire trace` output prints each relation as `formalized by <path>::<label>`."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-7, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace --prefix` includes the `formalizes` relations whose id matches the prefix."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-8, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire symbols --json` lists a formalized id, defined by the corpus, in the `formalizes` field of the declaring symbol."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-9, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "When the scope has no `spec/` directory, `quire symbols` succeeds and lists no formalized id, rather than failing on the missing document root."}
- {id: VER-75-AC-10, path: Linear VER-75, role: examined, excerpt: "With a module that declares no `trace_tags.formalizes`, a corpus containing `.native` files gives output byte-identical to the current output."}
- {id: FR-045, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace` SHALL carry the relation in its own `claims.formalizes` array beside `claims.verifies` and `claims.implements`."}
- {id: src/commands/trace.rs, path: src/commands/trace.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "struct ClaimsSection { verifies: Vec<VerifiesRecord>, implements: Vec<ImplementsRecord>, formalizes: Vec<FormalizesRecord> }"}
- {id: src/commands/coverage.rs, path: src/commands/coverage.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "resolve_formalizes_in_scope drops unresolved ids and clears relations when spec/ is absent."}
- {id: src/commands/symbols.rs, path: src/commands/symbols.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "The bound symbol graph is resolved against the corpus before building the symbol table."}
- {id: tests/cli_trace.rs, path: tests/cli_trace.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "Nine tagged CLI tests cover FR-045-AC-1 through FR-045-AC-9; none covers byte-identical output when the marker form is undeclared."}
- {id: Cargo.lock, path: Cargo.lock, role: examined, excerpt: "The quire-rs branch lock entry advances to the merged relation implementation."}
```

## Verdict

CONDITIONAL. The new relations are correctly kept separate from verifies and implements, resolve against the corpus, and have tagged acceptance tests. FND-001 prevents merging until the no-marker output contract is preserved.

## Dispositions

Round 1, fix head d5111ce.

| FND | Outcome | Reason |
| --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | fixed | `ClaimsSection.formalizes` now uses `#[serde(skip_serializing_if = "Vec::is_empty")]`, and `an_undeclared_formalizes_form_preserves_existing_trace_json_bytes` asserts the exact prior JSON bytes for a `.native` scope whose module does not declare the marker. FR-045 now states: `quire trace` SHALL omit `claims.formalizes` when no formalizes relation is present, preserving its existing JSON bytes for modules that do not declare a formalizes marker form. The regression test passed. |
49 changes: 49 additions & 0 deletions reviews/SR-20261113192642-ver-75-pr207-gap-analysis.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192642
title: "VER-75 quire-cli PR207 gap analysis"
type: SpecReview
analysis: gap-analysis
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; PR #207 spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, src/commands/trace.rs, src/commands/coverage.rs, src/commands/symbols.rs, tests/cli_trace.rs"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

Plan completion: not assessed. The computed matrix binds all nine FR-045 criteria to tagged tests, and the changed paths contain no stubs; reverse inspection found one observable JSON-shape change with no owning requirement or test: an empty `formalizes` array is emitted even when the module does not declare that marker.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs | Escape Cause |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | medium | `ClaimsSection` adds `formalizes: []` to trace JSON for modules with no formalizes relation. No FR-045 criterion specifies this unconditional empty field, and no test checks that behavior. It also conflicts with VER-75 AC-10's explicit byte-identical output requirement. Omit the empty field and add the compatibility regression case. | src/commands/trace.rs:224-228; tests/cli_trace.rs | missing-requirement |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-045-AC-1, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Forward trace JSON lists a resolved declaration only under claims.formalizes."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-2, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Inverse trace JSON lists each declaration and its resolved formalizes id."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-3, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "An id the corpus does not define appears in neither trace nor symbols JSON output."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-4, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "TSV emits one formalizes record per relation."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-5, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Trace succeeds and lists no formalizes relation when the scope has no spec directory."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-6, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Human output prints each relation as formalized by <path>::<label>."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-7, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Prefix trace includes matching formalizes relations."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-8, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Symbols JSON lists a corpus-defined formalized id on its declaring symbol."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-9, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Symbols succeeds and lists no formalized id when the scope has no spec directory."}
- {id: src/commands/trace.rs, path: src/commands/trace.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "The claims serializer includes all three vectors; formalizes has no skip-when-empty condition."}
- {id: src/commands/coverage.rs, path: src/commands/coverage.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "Unresolved formalizes ids are removed against the loaded spec corpus; a missing spec directory clears the graph relations."}
- {id: src/commands/symbols.rs, path: src/commands/symbols.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "The symbols command resolves a bound graph before building its symbol report."}
- {id: tests/cli_trace.rs, path: tests/cli_trace.rs, role: examined, excerpt: "All nine FR-045 criteria have a tagged CLI test; there is no test for output byte preservation when formalizes is undeclared."}
```

## Verdict

CONDITIONAL. The computed Test Matrix shows 9/9 FR-045 acceptance criteria tagged. One reverse gap remains for the empty JSON field; no plan was supplied, so plan completion was not assessed.

## Dispositions

Round 1, fix head d5111ce.

| FND | Outcome | Reason |
| --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | fixed | The empty JSON field is skipped and an exact-byte compatibility test covers a module without the marker form. FR-045 now states: `quire trace` SHALL omit `claims.formalizes` when no formalizes relation is present, preserving its existing JSON bytes for modules that do not declare a formalizes marker form. The matrix now covers AC-10 and its regression test passed. |
48 changes: 48 additions & 0 deletions reviews/SR-20261113192643-ver-75-pr207-spec-review-base.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192643
title: "VER-75 FR044 base spec review"
type: SpecReview
analysis: base
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md and its VER-75 ticket acceptance criteria"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

Base review of the new FR-045 found one missing requirement: the ticket requires no-marker projects to retain byte-identical output, but the FR does not constrain output when no formalizes marker is declared. No applicable AssuranceProfile was found in this repository. ID format and links validate; no hash, pin, version, or file-tracking ceremony was added.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | medium | FR-045 does not preserve VER-75 AC-10's explicit requirement that a corpus with no declared `trace_tags.formalizes` marker produce byte-identical output. Add a criterion for unchanged output and a test without the marker form; otherwise empty-field serialization is unconstrained. | spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md; Linear VER-75 AC-10 |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-045, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "`quire trace` SHALL carry the relation in its own `claims.formalizes` array beside `claims.verifies` and `claims.implements`."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-1, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Forward JSON lists the declaration under formalizes only and marks the result resolved."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-2, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Inverse JSON lists declarations with resolved ids."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-3, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Undefined ids appear in neither trace nor symbols JSON output."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-4, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "TSV emits one formalizes record per relation."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-5, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Trace succeeds with no formalizes relation when scope has no spec directory."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-6, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Human output prints each relation as formalized by <path>::<label>."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-7, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Prefix trace includes formalizes relations whose id matches the prefix."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-8, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Symbols JSON lists a corpus-defined id in its declaring symbol's formalizes field."}
- {id: FR-045-AC-9, path: spec/functional/FR-045-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Symbols succeeds with no formalized id when scope has no spec directory."}
- {id: VER-75-AC-10, path: Linear VER-75, role: examined, excerpt: "With a module that declares no `trace_tags.formalizes`, a corpus containing `.native` files gives output byte-identical to the current output."}
- {id: StR-004, path: spec/stakeholder/StR-004-thin-boundary-over-quire-rs.md, role: context_only, excerpt: "For artifact operations, the CLI SHALL be a thin process boundary over quire-rs."}
```

## Verdict

CONDITIONAL. The new relation behavior is scoped and testable, but the explicit no-marker compatibility obligation must be represented in the FR to constrain the stable JSON output.

## Dispositions

Round 1, fix head d5111ce.

| FND | Outcome | Reason |
| --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | fixed | FR-045 now includes AC-10: `With a module that does not declare trace_tags.formalizes and a scope containing a .native file with no formalizes relation, quire trace --id <ID> --json omits claims.formalizes and emits the same bytes as the existing trace JSON contract.` The new tagged exact-byte regression test passed. |
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192644
title: "VER-75 FR044 EARS conformance review"
type: SpecReview
analysis: ears-conformance
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

EARS review of the seven FR-044 requirement statements. `quire validate --scope . spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md --summary` reported the document grammar-clean with zero grammar findings; semantic inspection found no unverifiable response, misplaced trigger, or requirement whose wording changes the behavior built.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | low | No issues found (placeholder). | - |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-044, path: spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Seven `quire trace` and `quire symbols` SHALL statements define relation output, resolution, and missing-spec behavior."}
```

## Verdict

PASS. All requirement statements are classifiable and observable; the validator found no grammar warnings for this document.
31 changes: 31 additions & 0 deletions reviews/SR-20261113192645-ver-75-pr207-spec-review-integrity.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192645
title: "VER-75 FR044 integrity review"
type: SpecReview
analysis: integrity
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md, spec/functional/index.md"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

Integrity review checked FR-044's uniqueness, relationships, output contract, boundary assumptions, testability, and coverage. The nine criteria are observable and the computed matrix binds all nine to tagged tests; no cycle or contradictory output rule was found. The missing no-marker compatibility requirement is recorded in the base review.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | low | No additional integrity issues found (placeholder). | - |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-044, path: spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "The new CLI requirement delegates relation ownership and id resolution to quire-rs FR-094 and search shape to FR-077."}
- {id: FR-044-AC-1..9, path: spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "Each of the nine output and missing-spec criteria has a distinct observable test oracle."}
- {id: StR-004, path: spec/stakeholder/StR-004-thin-boundary-over-quire-rs.md, role: context_only, excerpt: "Artifact behavior stays a thin process boundary over the canonical quire-rs engine."}
```

## Verdict

PASS. The feature boundary is explicit, errors and missing-corpus behavior are stated, criteria are testable, and the computed matrix has no untagged FR-044 criterion.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
---
id: SR-20261113192646
title: "VER-75 FR044 dependency review"
type: SpecReview
analysis: dependency
scope: "agent-ix/quire-cli; spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md and referenced quire-rs requirements"
review_set: subset
---

## Summary

Dependency review traced the CLI feature to quire-rs FR-094 for the formalizes relation and FR-077 for the trace-search result shape. Both are upstream enablement; FR-044 is the CLI feature. The direction is acyclic and agrees with the VER-75 cross-repository landing order.

## Findings

| ID | Severity | Summary | Refs |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| FND-001 | low | No dependency or ordering issues found (placeholder). | - |

## Examined scope

```yaml
scope:
- {id: FR-044, path: spec/functional/FR-044-trace-formalizes-output.md, role: examined, excerpt: "FR-044 implements StR-004 and references quire-rs FR-094 and FR-077."}
- {id: FR-094, path: ix://agent-ix/quire-rs/FR-094, role: context_only, excerpt: "Upstream owner of the formalizes relation and resolution."}
- {id: FR-077, path: ix://agent-ix/quire-rs/FR-077, role: context_only, excerpt: "Upstream owner of the trace-search result shape."}
- {id: StR-004, path: spec/stakeholder/StR-004-thin-boundary-over-quire-rs.md, role: context_only, excerpt: "The CLI remains a thin process boundary and defers artifact semantics to quire-rs."}
```

## Verdict

PASS. The prerequisite direction is from the quire-rs relation and result-shape contracts to the CLI presentation feature; no cycle or enablement-order violation was found.
Loading
Loading