Re-apply "SCS-0128: Remove admin pass instance creation test" - #1253
toothstone wants to merge 2 commits into
Conversation
|
There was an agreement with @mbuechse that SCS-0128 will be amended to only require not failing any tests, so skipping tests is allowed. |
This was reverted in #1285, so I'll reopen this PR. There are valid security reasons to disallow instance creation with admin passwords, so SCS should not mandate this feature. |
|
You are right: on 2026-07-23 we decided to
And the latest change contradicts that, for the standard now says:
However, there is a priori no reason why the test case in question cannot be (made) one of those well-founded exceptions. Then again, it has to be discussed whether it should. The above-linked meeting minutes also state
I don't know what is meant here by 'is not a mandatory feature'. Mandatory -- mandated by whom? Maybe it was mandatory in OpenStack-powered Compute, maybe it wasn't. Regardless, I think we, the SCS community, should reconsider this matter and come to a (loose) consensus what we want:
So I'm adding this to the SIG agenda. |
Recreation of #1245 after it was erroneously merged and had to be reverted in #1250
Only applicable once #1250 is merged.