Skip to content

Track WP26 CubeSat and stakeholder-chain editor feedback #35

Open

Description

@rororowyourboat

Track Zargham’s 2026-11-10 CubeSat/stakeholder-model feedback against the view editor. This is intake, not evidence that maintainers have reproduced or accepted every reported expectation.

Report pinned to the reported revision · 31 screenshots · Model sources.

Reported bugs and missing capabilities

Stakeholder-to-evidence chain

F-5 is combined with Bug 4 above because they require the same case-rendering capability.

Other actionable suggestions and reading workflows

Evidence and scope rules

  • Bug 1 did not reproduce in the report’s cold pass. Bug 2 may reflect the last successful save, and later instances followed a competing-tab save failure; silent loss has not been established.
  • Bugs 8–9 are parser disagreements requiring authoritative semantic analysis. Another parser accepting source does not establish correctness.
  • Bug 6 compares different filters/projections; verify exposure, filter and representation semantics independently before treating the difference as a defect.
  • The app already supports multi-file import. Bug 3 requests adding files to an existing open project.
  • The dated hosted build was not identified by commit. Compare each finding with an exact current build and engine pins before claiming a fix or deployment.
  • The report’s screenshot-lag observation (section 2 item 11) has no established editor cause. Qualify whether it belongs to the browser/automation capture surface before filing a product defect. External tab navigation/interference was explicitly excluded by the report.
  • Preserve the successes: named views, source/issue inspection, requirements and negated satisfaction, CSV/matrix workflows, and the distinction between declared verification and executed results.
  • No delivery dates, assignments, conformance decisions, local reproductions or deployed fixes are implied by this intake. The editor guide merged in PR feat: add optional accessible editor guide #13 addresses discoverability, not proof that the reported usability concerns are resolved.

Issues were requested in this repository only; no GitHub Project board was created or populated.

Implementation update — 2026-11-11

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    Priority

    None yet

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions