You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
README: say reviewer findings need a plugin forge (GitHub Labs get no review comments) #385
The README's early-release note (README.md:32) says findings from outside reviewers "come back as fix rounds that you approve before anything is pushed". It doesn't say this works only on a plugin forge such as GitLab.
On a GitHub Lab, every collection fails with "this forge does not serve review comments". The Findings tab never fills, so a GitHub user who reads the README and adds a reviewer gets nothing. docs/install.md:129-130 and plugins/forgecomments/README.md both state the limit; the README is the only place that leaves it out.
Found while walking through the Findings tab on Molecule 359 (PR #374) in a scratch copy of the Lab.
Change
Add one short clause to the README note saying outside reviewers need a plugin forge, and that GitHub Labs can't serve review comments yet. Link to the install.md section.
lab/internal/ui/molecule_findings_ui_test.go:266 bans some phrases, such as "outside reviewers are not supported yet". Word the caveat so it says what works instead of calling the feature unsupported.
Done when
The README says GitHub Labs don't get reviewer comments yet, in the same place it promises fix rounds.
Activity
README: say reviewer findings need a plugin forge (#385) (#387)
DanielNetzer commentedon Nov 6, 2026
Fixed in #387.