diff --git a/docs/PUBLICATION-NOTES.md b/docs/PUBLICATION-NOTES.md index 922aa66..b95a9d8 100644 --- a/docs/PUBLICATION-NOTES.md +++ b/docs/PUBLICATION-NOTES.md @@ -94,15 +94,42 @@ updated; rababa RESULTS.md carries both tables. Follow-on (user decision): ara-diac-2.0 teacher release; students re-distilled from r7 with Muon (E3) are the natural ara-diac-small-2.0. -## Venue fit (working notes) - -The spine is systems-with-measurements: an artifact contract + -distillation discipline + three calibration/measurement corrections -(decode, subset, quantization-margins) that generalize beyond our -stack. The frontier law (pretrained-or-collapse) and the controlled -capacity/aux/optimizer experiments give it empirical heft. Package as -one paper (current paper.adoc); the margin/head finding alone is also -a strong short workshop paper if a split is ever wanted. +## Venue decision (2026-08-29): TWO papers + a benchmark-backed third + +The material outgrew one paper. Split by **teacher vs student**, not +training vs distillation — the 2x2 factorial gap decomposition is a +distillation-training result and must stay with the student paper. + +**Paper A — teacher** (facts 1, 2, 8): "Morphological supervision, +not phonemic: controlled evidence and a dual-surface teacher for +Arabic diacritization." r8 single-variable aux ablation (morph +2.5793 < IPA 2.6588 < none 2.6775 - the strong form of "phonemes +help" fails), r7 dual-surface domain adaptation (ID 2.2864 / OOD +17.38-11.83, trade-off gone), protocol-matched leaderboard with the +full-set-only rule. 100% measured, writable now. ACL/EMNLP main or +SEMITIC. + +**Paper B — student** (facts 3-7, 9-11, 13-14): "Closing the +teacher-student gap for browser-tier byte-level seq2seq." Spine: the +2x2 factorial (optimizer -2.96pp, memory -0.70pp, combined -3.43pp, +~additive, residual 2.25pp = domain). Pretrained-or-collapse law in +two languages with the label-provenance forensics arc (83.08 -> +83.0797 -> 74.68) as the reproducibility section; decode-protocol +correction (beam inflates 4.2x) and margins/head-fp32 (36x flip +reduction at +0.4% size) as calibration sections; the SVD-stitch +rung as the browser-budget ending (if it fails, the shipped +ByT5-small int8 tiers end the paper instead). IMF v1 as the artifact +appendix. Efficient-NLP/distillation venue with artifact badge. + +**Paper C — systems** (fact 11 + the runtime stack): gated on a real +evaluation axis. Benchmarks to build (benchmarks/imf-runtime): +decode latency x tier x runtime backend (onnxruntime-node, Modal +4-vCPU serving shape, browser WASM/WebGPU), cold load vs cache-hit, +zip+member verification overhead, session-create cost, peak memory, +index-resolution latency. Without these it stays an appendix. + +Fact allocation table (14 facts -> papers): A: 1, 2, 8. B: 3, 4, 5, +6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 14. C: 11, 12 + new benchmark results. ## ara-diac-tiny: the "clean-label re-run" wasn't (2026-08-29)