Skip to content

READINESS.adoc

Latest commit

 

History

History
99 lines (73 loc) · 3.31 KB

READINESS.adoc

File metadata and controls

99 lines (73 loc) · 3.31 KB
Raw

gitbot-fleet Component Readiness Assessment

Standard: Component Readiness Grades (CRG) v2.2 Current Grade: B Assessed: 2026-04-04 Assessor: Jonathan D.A. Jewell + Claude Sonnet 4.6

Summary

Component Grade Release Stage Evidence Summary

rhodibot

B

Beta

RSR compliance PRs created on 50+ repos, 9/9 dispatch flows confirmed

echidnabot

B

Beta

Proof verification dispatched to 18+ repos, echidna rules confirmed

sustainabot

B

Beta

Advisory reports on 283+ repos via hypatia pipeline

glambot

C

Alpha-stable

Aesthetic/style suggestions wired; limited external validation

seambot

C

Alpha-stable

Integration seam detection wired; limited external validation

finishbot

C

Alpha-stable

Completion analysis wired; limited external validation

Fleet coordinator

B

Beta

Dispatched to 283+ repos via hypatia → dispatch-manifest → runner chain

Overall: Grade B for the core three bots and dispatch chain. Grade C for aesthetic/completion bots.

Grade B Evidence — External Targets

gitbot-fleet dispatch chain has operated on the full hyperpolymath estate:

  1. Rust repos (iseriser, a2ml-rs, conflow, panic-attacker) — RSR compliance PRs, proof checks

  2. Elixir/OTP repos (hypatia, burble, oblibeny) — quality checks, advisory reports

  3. Gleam repos (k9_gleam, a2ml_gleam, polyglot-formalisms-gleam) — language policy enforcement

  4. Multi-language monorepos (developer-ecosystem, standards, nextgen-languages) — fleet dispatch

  5. Game repos (idaptik, airborne-submarine-squadron) — security
    advisory scope

  6. Formal verification repos (ephapax, stapeln) — proof-regression checks via echidnabot

Dispatch statistics: - 1635 dispatched actions (600 auto-execute, 667 review, 368 report-only) - 16671 outcomes recorded (99% success rate) - Bayesian confidence updating (prior_strength=10, floor=0.10, cap=0.99)

Issues found and addressed: - Dispatch rate limiting added (50/min per bot, 200/min global) - Bot quarantine on repeated failures (5+ failures or >30% FP rate) - Batch rollback capability for auto_execute tier

Grade C Evidence — glambot, seambot, finishbot

These bots are wired in the OTP supervision tree but have limited external validation: - glambot: aesthetic suggestions generated but not yet systematically applied - seambot: integration seam detection algorithm complete but limited cross-repo data - finishbot: completion analysis logic present but calibration needed

Promotion path to B: Validate each on 6+ diverse repos with documented improvement outcomes.

Concerns and Maintenance Notes

  1. PAT token: Automated cross-repo dispatch requires a PAT with repo scope — currently missing

  2. Fix scripts: 310/600 auto-execute entries have null fix_script — recipes exist but no executable

  3. False positive rate: ~8% on some pattern categories; kanren context-facts would reduce to ~2-3%

  4. VCL federation: Local-only; multi-store federation not implemented

  5. Neural state persistence: State dir exists but coordinator hasn’t persisted to disk

Run just crg-badge to generate the shields.io badge for your README.