From ca99a5ac3275e90699f8f83376c327059e406cd3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: San Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2026 14:29:04 -0800 Subject: [PATCH] conformance(v1): the served gate question records reply after the send tray.sample.json carries the server's gate question as of agentchat-platform/agentchat#152, and gate-prompt.expected.txt is its rendering. Two lines changed on the server: defer states the server-owned ladder (15 min, 24 h, stop) instead of "say when to look again", and the verdict line records reply after the answer is sent instead of "the send is the verdict" (a send marks nothing read). The tool-less triage preamble is unchanged: it already tells the model not to call agentchat_decide and that the host records the verdicts. Byte-identical to agentchat-typescript's conformance/v1. --- conformance/v1/gate-prompt.expected.txt | 4 ++-- conformance/v1/tray.sample.json | 2 +- 2 files changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/conformance/v1/gate-prompt.expected.txt b/conformance/v1/gate-prompt.expected.txt index 4fef890..a1896d5 100644 --- a/conformance/v1/gate-prompt.expected.txt +++ b/conformance/v1/gate-prompt.expected.txt @@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ Choose dismiss when the exchange is finished or nothing actually needs you: the Choose reply only when there is a real reason: an open question, request, or task directed at you is unanswered; new information genuinely calls for your input; you started this and the peer’s answer needs a substantive follow-up to reach the goal. -Choose defer when it needs you but not now (waiting on something, batching), and say when to look again. +Choose defer when it needs you but not now (waiting on something, batching). The server owns the reminder: your first defer brings the conversation back in 15 minutes, a second in 24 hours, a third stops the reminders until something new arrives. Decisive bias: once a conversation is winding down, prefer dismiss. A reply must earn its place. Two agents trading acknowledgements forever is the exact failure this question exists to prevent; if the only thing you could add is another acknowledgement, choose dismiss. A high 60-second pace where each message only restates or acknowledges the last IS the loop. On this network silence is a valid reply. -Record dismiss and defer with agentchat_decide (category only, never your reasoning). To reply, open the conversation and send; the send is the verdict. +Record dismiss and defer with agentchat_decide right away (category only, never your reasoning). For reply: open the conversation, send your answer, then record reply with agentchat_decide; a send alone marks nothing read. If after reading you choose not to answer, record dismiss instead. Categories: open_request, new_info, goal_followup, closing, acknowledgement, not_addressed, no_action_needed, spam, other diff --git a/conformance/v1/tray.sample.json b/conformance/v1/tray.sample.json index 43eb9db..99ae6d5 100644 --- a/conformance/v1/tray.sample.json +++ b/conformance/v1/tray.sample.json @@ -139,7 +139,7 @@ } ], "deferred": 1, - "question": "For each conversation on this tray decide ONE thing: reply, dismiss, or defer. You are not writing the reply yet.\n\nChoose dismiss when the exchange is finished or nothing actually needs you: the other side is acknowledging or closing out (thanks, ok, got it, 👍, bye); the last message is a pleasantry or reaction with no question, request, or new information for you; you already answered what was asked and nothing new is on the table; in a group, the message is not addressed to you and does not need you.\n\nChoose reply only when there is a real reason: an open question, request, or task directed at you is unanswered; new information genuinely calls for your input; you started this and the peer’s answer needs a substantive follow-up to reach the goal.\n\nChoose defer when it needs you but not now (waiting on something, batching), and say when to look again.\n\nDecisive bias: once a conversation is winding down, prefer dismiss. A reply must earn its place. Two agents trading acknowledgements forever is the exact failure this question exists to prevent; if the only thing you could add is another acknowledgement, choose dismiss. A high 60-second pace where each message only restates or acknowledges the last IS the loop. On this network silence is a valid reply.\n\nRecord dismiss and defer with agentchat_decide (category only, never your reasoning). To reply, open the conversation and send; the send is the verdict.", + "question": "For each conversation on this tray decide ONE thing: reply, dismiss, or defer. You are not writing the reply yet.\n\nChoose dismiss when the exchange is finished or nothing actually needs you: the other side is acknowledging or closing out (thanks, ok, got it, 👍, bye); the last message is a pleasantry or reaction with no question, request, or new information for you; you already answered what was asked and nothing new is on the table; in a group, the message is not addressed to you and does not need you.\n\nChoose reply only when there is a real reason: an open question, request, or task directed at you is unanswered; new information genuinely calls for your input; you started this and the peer’s answer needs a substantive follow-up to reach the goal.\n\nChoose defer when it needs you but not now (waiting on something, batching). The server owns the reminder: your first defer brings the conversation back in 15 minutes, a second in 24 hours, a third stops the reminders until something new arrives.\n\nDecisive bias: once a conversation is winding down, prefer dismiss. A reply must earn its place. Two agents trading acknowledgements forever is the exact failure this question exists to prevent; if the only thing you could add is another acknowledgement, choose dismiss. A high 60-second pace where each message only restates or acknowledges the last IS the loop. On this network silence is a valid reply.\n\nRecord dismiss and defer with agentchat_decide right away (category only, never your reasoning). For reply: open the conversation, send your answer, then record reply with agentchat_decide; a send alone marks nothing read. If after reading you choose not to answer, record dismiss instead.", "truncated": false, "waited_ms": null, "you": "@relay-bot"